Welcome
Welcome to the <strong>fanfictioncritiquegroup</strong>.

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest, which gives you only limited access to view most discussions and access some features. By joining our free community, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free, so please, <a href="/profile.php?mode=register">join our community today</a>!

Week 65: April 19, 2009


Our Weekly featured pieces. :)

Moderator: kazalene

User avatar

Moderator

Posts: 204

Joined: Sun Jun 01, 2008 12:43 am

Location: Procrastination Central

Post Mon Apr 20, 2009 2:44 am

Week 65: April 19, 2009

Oops, as Giorgia correctly pointed out I made an error when updating the FCG this week. Sorry, guys, I was in the process of powering out a horrific law assignment that's due in about two hours. All night working sessions destroy my brain cells.

The Tension and The Spark
By: Kazalene
CSI: Miami
Linkity

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

TQ: Discuss your favourite writing techniques. What makes them so effective and why do you love to use them? Do some stories make better use of them than others?

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

All critiques are due by this Saturday. The next featured story will be posted on Sunday, April 26, 2009.

Remember, if you want to be critiqued, you have to critique the week before!
Last edited by kazalene on Mon Apr 20, 2009 7:30 am, edited 2 times in total.
Proof-read carefully to see if you any words out.
User avatar

Pencil

Posts: 492

Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2008 1:45 am

Location: Alderon

Post Mon Apr 20, 2009 4:44 am

Is this a deliberate re-post?

Coz this fic (though awesome, and I'm going to read it again anyway) was featured a few weeks ago. Week 61, or thereabouts...

...?
"You smiled; and then I knew why Debbie calls you 'Sunshine'."
User avatar

Moderator

Posts: 204

Joined: Sun Jun 01, 2008 12:43 am

Location: Procrastination Central

Post Mon Apr 20, 2009 7:29 am

My bad, sorry. :( I've changed it now, though.
Proof-read carefully to see if you any words out.
User avatar

Eraser

Posts: 60

Joined: Sat May 31, 2008 10:04 pm

Location: Stuck in the middle with you

Post Fri Apr 24, 2009 2:08 am

Whew! I'm glad this semester is almost over...all I have left are the revisions to my last project and I'm done done done :mrgreen:



TQ: Discuss your favourite writing techniques. What makes them so effective and why do you love to use them? Do some stories make better use of them than others?

This one is the hardest TQ we’ve had yet, I swear. I honestly can’t think of any specific techniques that I use, mostly because I think it’s easier to critique someone else’s work than it is your own. I do know that I almost exclusively use small words when I write so the reader doesn’t have to sit with a dictionary next to them, but I also tend to use longer sentences to make sure that the appropriate amount of detail is included. Like Giorgia said a few weeks ago, my style is simple, but not, and I think that’s an accurate description. I want to engage my readers but not leave them with migraines!

I also use OC’s a lot of the time, almost all of whom are your average-everyday-relatively-normal young women. The average-everyday-relatively-normal quality is important to me because I like realism in my fanfiction, even when it’s an escape for me or just a nice way to pass the time. There are so many stories out there where the author seems to just be writing what s/he wants to see happen regardless of the reality of the situation (you know the ones I’m talking about—where Calleigh and Eric kiss and get engaged in about five minutes, where Mac and Stella have a secret love child that comes to work in the Crime Lab and falls hopelessly in love with Flack, where…well, you get the idea) and they all seem so contrived. I like a story that feels real, and I try to write that way too.


Critique

Things to work on:
I only found two grammar points to mention and neither detracted a bit from the story—
• It never usually bothered her, though Usually never? You can only have one or the other :D

• Both of them, maybe, because suddenly his mouth was on hers; hers on his. Oy with the semicolons! (Sorry Giorgia :P ) You actually used the semicolon correctly every other time, but not in this particular instance. A semicolon is supposed to separate two clauses that could stand on their own as full sentences.


Things that were good:
Where do I begin? How ’bout flow…characterization…readability (is that a word or have I been watching too many beer commercials?)…or just that nice, warm/fuzzy feeling that I got reading this? I don’t know, but it was all good, just as I’ve come to expect from you. I’ve admittedly been getting a little weary of EC fics because they were so abundant before this season and now they’re just everywhere, but this one is definitely an exception. You caught my interest (Why is Calleigh walking around in the dark? Where is she walking?!) and kept it easily even though the will-they-or-won’t-they storyline has been done more times then I’ve had to repeat directions in my classroom. Perhaps I’m just a sucker for a sweet ending, but the warm/fuzziness really kicked in at the end—there’s just something about falling asleep together that I’ve always been particularly fond of.

And, on a very, very side note, can I just say that I think your section separators are very cool 8-)
"If you always do what you've always done, then you'll always get what you always got."

Tony DiNozzo, NCIS
User avatar

Pencil

Posts: 492

Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2008 1:45 am

Location: Alderon

Post Fri Apr 24, 2009 11:43 am

TQ: Discuss your favourite writing techniques. What makes them so effective and why do you love to use them? Do some stories make better use of them than others?

Okay, I'm using this answer legitimately (i.e. not as a cop-out), but I think that it all depends on the author.

I never used to like AU fics until I found a site with really good WATFF ones that were absolutely amazing, and well worth reading, well-written, clever, intricate, witty and in character.

I don't really like song-fics, but some of the ones I've read are fantastic, if the lyrics are incorporated well, relevant and not a really, really bad song (which makes it hard to take anything seriously).

Stories without speech can be incredibly dull, or incredibly effective, depending entirely on whether the author's done a good job.

I tend not to like stories with only speech, either, but I've rea d a few that have made me giggle.

Drabbles are kind of the same: really bad or really good. If an author can write something worthwhile in a couple hundred words, then sure.

I read a really good story a while ago that had speech, but it wasn't spoken, as such. As in, there were no speech marks. There would be a paragraph of insight into the character's head, then just a single line in italics which was the dialogue.

And the whole story went that way: paragraph, line, paragraph, line.

And it was really very effective because it portrayed exactly what the story was presenting, which was a weird melancholy calm.

There's another author I know of who can write anything from totally plotless smut to totally innocent fluff in the most intelligent and hysterically funny way. And it works, because they're genuinely good at it.

As for what I like to use, that's a totally different story.

I think that the writing techniques I use tend to basically set themselves up. I don't sit at the computer and think, "Okay, so which writing style will best put across the mood I want?", mostly because I'm too lazy, but hey.

But I think (hope, really) that a good story almost writes itself.

I've written one or two stories with absolutely no speech, and that wasn't really deliberate at all. I just didn't have anything for the characters to say, because there was too much else going on and I didn't want to 'break the moment'.

I've written stories will painfully little description (though I tend much more toward the opposite).

Though, all that said, I do prefer more descriptive writing. I either like writing something that is in a very sarcastic, flippant manner (because it's just fun to be flip sometimes), or I write something that is more... poetic?

I think that you can get across different parts of different genres depending on how you do this. I mean, it's really, really hard to write good angst when you're writing like everything is absolutely hilarious.

Amounts of dialogue usually just kind of follow. Usually, if I'm writing angsty stuff, I don't use as much speech beuase it usually a little more about emotion and inner turmoil. Whereas if I'm writing something more sarcastically, dialogue adds another dimension.

Any style can work, as long as it doesn't read as forced. If I have to sit down and think about what type of sentences and what kind of words and what style of language to use, then I usually just leave the story/idea and get back to it later, or alter it so it feels natural. Otherwise it's no fun to write, and too hard for others to read.

That all said, for all I know, my writing style may be absolutely horrid, so. Hehe.



Critique:

This was a great story. I still don't watch CSI: Miami (and am probably going to continuously point this out for every story I read for it) but I'm liking this pairing more and more each time you guys feature one.

She took the long sigh he exhaled to be his agreement, and wondered briefly if the case had brought back memories of his own shooting... and then scolded herself for even thinking it; he needed her support, not her doubt, and certainly not her -

This sentence, though not really wrong, has a lot of... stuff in it. Comma, semicolon, ellipses and hyphen. Though it reads well it a bit awkward, grammatically.



Blood; fingerprints; blood; a 45.; blood; GSR; blood...


This was interesting. It was like the sort of quick, flashing montages the CSI's have and it linked the story back to the reality of the show. I could literally see them flashing through my head (in my head they were black-and-white, for some reason, too) with the whoosh sort of sound that usually accompanies them.

Don't know why that struck me so much; just liked the imagery, there.

I know it's not really pertinent, but I liked your page-breaks. Hehe. I use actual HTML page-breaks, and it can often get a bit too separated. And some people use, like, on dot, and you just miss it entirely, which drives me nuts, because then something's quadruple-spaced and half way down the page without some kind of symbol that implies it should be. And I should stop talking about this like it's some kind of mania, shouldn't I?

Are page-breaks a normal thing to talk about? Hm.

Oh, the scene in the break room was superb. I was aching for a kiss, there. I don't know anything about Calleigh's mother, but I write enough characters with parental issues to know something of it, and the little understanding that they have there is great.

It never usually bothered her, though, but now it only seemed to serve as a distraction; the tall, dark and handsome figure in the lab adjacent to hers was proving far too entertaining to look at for her liking.


Hehe, loved this sentence.

He was waiting for her when she got home, body leaning against the brick of her house, the fading sunlight reflecting against the buttons on his jacket, and instantly she felt her breath hitch.


I love the little detail about the buttons, here. All of your imagery is wonderful, by the way. It says so much and shows so much without trawling paragraphs of wordiness. (An I know I just invented, like, a whole sentence, but hey).

I just about danced when they finally kissed. Seriously, Kaz, less than 2500 words and you've got me waiting for a kiss. Genius. Mean, but genius. I might, here, also mention that I have a thing for walls in kisses. Or kisses-and-walls.

Goes well with everything, too; having described him as "The Passion" just a few paragraphes earlier.

Saying nothing more, she led him down her hallway and up the stairs to her bedroom, where he closed the door behind them.


I think it's the finality of this, or something, but the fact that Eric closes the door just stood out to me. In a good way. I mean, they're totally alone - it's her own house, yeah? - and it's not like they're tearing each other's clothes off, but it's like they're blocking the world out totally.

Everything and everyone is out there, and we're in here. Which is interesting, because you've earlier mentioned that it's no longer the outside influences that keep them apart, but themselves. Which makes it appropriate that they are the ones to block everything out, but lock themselves in, and I'm much too tired to be getting ironic or philosophic right now.

Loved the ending, too. *Sigh* Wish I had an Eric. Hehe.

Finally, and aptly so, I loved the title. It definitely shows the story for what it is.

The tension and the spark?

Oh, yes.
"You smiled; and then I knew why Debbie calls you 'Sunshine'."
User avatar

Moderator

Posts: 204

Joined: Sun Jun 01, 2008 12:43 am

Location: Procrastination Central

Post Sun Apr 26, 2009 12:05 am

Thank you for the critiques :D. They made a very nice distraction from my evil evil property law revision. Ugh, it's horrid.

Anyway, nice spot on that semi-colon, Zelda. It was actually supposed to be a simple colon 8-).

Oh, and Giorgia? I love love LOVE that you picked up on every single literary device I used in this story (the black and white flashbacks, Eric closing the door, the imagery, and what I was trying to create with the break room scene). You've got some mad-crazy critiquing skills! Although, regarding that sentence you pointed out with all the punctuation, it was supposed to reflect a thought trail... with lots of chopping a changing.

[align=center]- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -[/align]

TQ: Discuss your favourite writing techniques. What makes them so effective and why do you love to use them? Do some stories make better use of them than others?

My favourite technique has to be punctuation! There is SO much you can do with it... especially with ellipsis. You can highlight something, reinforce something, enhance the 'atmosphere, be stylised... the possibilities are endless. It's effective because it's so simple and yet can change everything. And I think that's why I love to use it... that and the fact that it's the correct thing to do, of course.

Another favourite is imagery, as it kinda serves like punctuation in that you can make an easy comment on your prose in so few words. Plus, it makes things sound pretty. 8-)

Being abstract and offering a different view-point on something is also another technique I love to use as not only does it create originality, it challenges me and occasionally gives me a nice, hopefully clever, little twist to my stories.

I think some stories do definitely make better use of techniques than others. Those without any techniques generally aren't as engrossing as those that incorporate them. But then it also depends on the type of story and the writer themselves as to whether they're effective or not.
Proof-read carefully to see if you any words out.
User avatar

Eraser

Posts: 74

Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2008 10:43 pm

Location: I'M A BOAT

Post Sun Apr 26, 2009 6:15 pm

TQ: Discuss your favourite writing techniques. What makes them so effective and why do you love to use them? Do some stories make better use of them than others?

My inferior teenaged brain cannot handle the question. D; Pass.

Critique:

I don't know what I could hit on that everybody else already has, but I can tell you the parts that I liked the most. C:

Leaning her back against the railing of the pier, she took a moment to study her surroundings, instinct keeping her alert. Bal Harbour was always buzzing in the evening. The St. Regis Hotel offered an exclusive playground for the rich to enjoy, whilst various restaurants and bars littered the area, attracting fashionistas and celebrities alike. And then of course there was the beach; stunning around the clock.

The pier had always been a source of clarity for her; she'd often found herself standing at the end of it and looking out across the bay after particularly gruelling cases. It was a rule she had, to never bring the emotional weight of her work back home. And here, she could let her thoughts go and the silence would listen, like an old, faithful friend. But, lately, it wasn't really the cases that were getting to her, and the wooden planks that once offered her comfort and peace now brought her only confusion.


I loved these two paragraphs. C: (slight typo: gruelling should be grueling) They gave me chills - the good chills - and were just awesome.

"No," she heard herself whisper. "Just... stay with me tonight?" She breathed a sigh of relief when he nodded, sighed again when he gently let her down from his grasp. Saying nothing more, she led him down her hallway and up the stairs to her bedroom, where he closed the door behind them. He watched her climb into her bed, seemed uncertain, hesitant, for a moment. But the it's okay smile she offered him seemed to quell any doubts he may have had, for suddenly his shoes were off, his clothing stripped to that of his boxers and his t-shirt.

And then he was beside her, the warmth of his body and the gentle movements of his fingers in her hair lulling her into a deep sleep, leaving her with the knowing feeling that she could get lost like this, with him.

And leaving her with the realisation that she wanted to.

And this... 8DDD

I wish I could quote the whole thing and say that I loved it all (because I really did), but that'd be too long.

So, really, you don't have anything to change that the people here have already mentioned. C: Awesome job! <33
Allow me to exaggerate a memory or two
Where summers lasted longer than, longer than we do
And nothing really mattered except for me to be with you
But in time we all forgot and we all grew
- "Folkin' Around", Panic! at the disco
User avatar

Moderator

Posts: 204

Joined: Sun Jun 01, 2008 12:43 am

Location: Procrastination Central

Post Sun Apr 26, 2009 6:33 pm

peaceloverainbow wrote:(slight typo: gruelling should be grueling)


You crazy Americans take a 'l' out of gruelling?! I know us Brits differ on spellings quite a bit but I never knew that one.

Ohhh, but then I guess its a phonetics thing. Like, I'd say Gruel-ling. You guys must say, Gruel-ing.
Proof-read carefully to see if you any words out.
User avatar

Pencil

Posts: 492

Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2008 1:45 am

Location: Alderon

Post Mon Apr 27, 2009 9:20 am

I thought it looked a bit off with only one 'l'. Spellings are annoying. I wrote an essay the other day and Microsoft Word all auto-correcty on me.

So I went back to change it, which annoyed me almost as much, because I have a slight complex when it comes to the red-squiggly-lines.

Anyway...
"You smiled; and then I knew why Debbie calls you 'Sunshine'."
User avatar

Eraser

Posts: 74

Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2008 10:43 pm

Location: I'M A BOAT

Post Tue Apr 28, 2009 12:19 am

D:

I'm sorry! I didn't know you were British. DX

My bad.
Allow me to exaggerate a memory or two
Where summers lasted longer than, longer than we do
And nothing really mattered except for me to be with you
But in time we all forgot and we all grew
- "Folkin' Around", Panic! at the disco

Return to Featured Fanfictions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

cron
Donate Now
Donate Now


Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by ST Software for PTF.
Hosted by FreeForums.org | Create a free forum